If there's one thing I've learned over the years of research into Diet and Nutrition, it's this: Everyone is Different. When I first discovered low-carbohydrate diets (thanks to the late Dr Robert C. Atkins M.D.), I thought that it was the One True Diet, and I became a bit of an "Atkins bore" telling everyone how wonderful it was and suggesting that everyone should be on it. I now know that what suits me doesn't necessarily suit everyone else.
To illustrate how variable people are, here's Fig. 2 from Determinants of the variability in respiratory exchange ratio at rest and during exercise in trained athletes. Used with permission.
Respiratory Exchange Ratio (RER) (a.k.a. Respiratory Quotient (RQ)) is the ratio of carbon dioxide breathed out to oxygen breathed in. This ratio depends on the fuels that the body is burning for energy. For example, if the body is burning 100% fats, RER = 0.7. If the body is burning 100% carbohydrates aerobically, RER=1.0. If the body is burning 100% carbohydrates anaerobically (flat-out sprinting), RER > 1.0. RER goes up and down depending on intensity of exercise, food intake (eating protein and/or carbohydrate increases it and extended fasting reduces it). Increasing cardiovascular fitness reduces RER.
The top diagram is a histogram of fasted RER and % fat oxidation vs. number of subjects. At the left-hand end of the histogram, there are two cyclists with a fat oxidation of 93 - 100%. At the right-hand end of the histogram, there is one cyclist with a fat oxidation of 20 - 27%.
There's a helluva difference between burning 93 - 100% fats at rest and burning 20 - 27% fats at rest!
As exercise intensity increases, the peak in the histogram shifts to the right as shown in the lower diagram. At 25% full work-load, mean fat oxidation is ~53%. At 50% full work-load, mean fat oxidation is ~37% and at 75% full work-load, mean fat oxidation is ~13%.
I suspect that at 100% full work-load, mean fat oxidation is 0% i.e. 100% of energy is obtained from carbohydrates when sprinting. Somebody on a very-low-carbohydrate diet like Atkins induction (~20g net carbs/day) could keel over with hypoglycaemia if they exercise for too long at too high an intensity.
As there is so much variation from person to person, you must find out for yourself your own optimum proportions of proteins, fats & carbohydrates, and these depend upon the intensity & volume of exercise you do. It all sounds rather complicated, but it isn't really.
Apply the principle of "Eat, monitor & adjust accordingly" as Toxic Toffee (ex-Muscletalk member) always used to say. The eating bit will be covered in future Blog posts. The monitoring bit doesn't necessarily involve bathroom scales.
Hang on. Isn't "dieting" all about losing excess weight? Not necessarily. Remember the old joke?
Q. What's the best way to lose 5lbs of ugly flab?
A. Cut off your head!
As your body contains water, muscle, bodyfat, bones, cartilage, tendons, organs, glycogen, skin etc and your scales can't tell the difference between them, losing weight the wrong way can make you less healthy. However, losing weight the right way will make you more healthy.
If you starve, skip breakfast or go for a long run before breakfast, as your body is lacking glycogen reserves & amino acids, a large amount of a corticosteroid hormone called cortisol is secreted, which increases the conversion of muscle into amino acids, then glucose. As muscle has an energy density of ~600kcal/lb, a deficit of 3,500kcal (which would result in a bodyfat loss of only 1lb) results in a muscle loss of 5.8lb! For more information, see The Energy Balance Equation.
Chronically-high cortisol also suppresses the immune system and weakens skin & bones.
Unless you have a lot of muscle mass to spare, it's bodyfat that you should be losing, and to monitor this, either use a tape-measure around your waist, check how loose/tight your clothes are, or strip-off and jump up & down in front of a full-length mirror. As Big Les (Muscletalk Moderator) says, "If it jiggles, it's fat!".
2016 EDIT: Scales that can calculate bodyfat % etc are now inexpensive, e.g. Body Analysis Scale. I was lucky enough to buy one on special offer for £14.99.
So, what happens if you eat too much carbohydrate but your body doesn't burn it fast enough? Initially, carbohydrate intake tops-up liver and muscle glycogen stores, which increases carbohydrate-burning to compensate. The liver can store about 70g of glycogen and muscles can store about 400g of glycogen. If, despite increased carbohydrate-burning, more carbohydrate is consumed than is burned, glycogen stores continue to fill. When glycogen stores become full, RER increases to 1.0 and 100% of energy is derived from carbohydrate. Getting 100% of energy from carbohydrate means that zero fat is burned, so filling glycogen stores to the brim by eating too much carbohydrate is not a good idea if you want to burn some body-fat.
Once glycogen stores are full, any additional intake of carbohydrate beyond that which is burned passes through the lipogenesis pathway - this basically means that carbs are turned into fat - which may end up as liver fat. But there's even worse news. Fat is secreted by the liver into the blood as triglycerides. This is bad for the cholesterol particles in your blood. See Cholesterol and Coronary Heart Disease. What happens if you eat too few carbs? As stated above, a "carbohydrate-burner" taking in insufficient carbohydrates could get hypoglycaemia & keel over.
How many grams of carbohydrate per day does it take to promote lipogenesis? Someone at rest burns ~1kcal/minute. If this is derived 100% from carbohydrate, this is equivalent to 0.25g of carbohydrate/minute, or 15g of carbohydrate/hour, or 360g of carbohydrate/day. Therefore, sedentary people who consistently eat more than 360g of carbohydrate/day may produce significant triglycerides. People who have The Metabolic Syndrome/Syndrome-X (a high proportion of people who have excess belly fat) have increased lipogenesis and higher serum triglycerides than healthy people.
Discussing weight again for a moment, it's often said that all diets are the same, as weight loss is all about calories. This is true. See Is a Calorie a Calorie? However, body composition is determined by a combination of macro-nutrient proportions (i.e. the relative amounts of proteins, carbohydrates and fats in the diet) and the intensity & volume of exercise. Health is determined by a combination of micro-nutrient proportions (i.e. vitamins, minerals & anutrients) and exercise. See On burning, storing and recomposing.
If you're only interested in weight loss, just count calories. If you wish to lose bodyfat without losing muscle mass, you need to know what proportions of proteins, carbohydrates & fats to eat (it's really not that critical, but many people get it wrong). You need to know the difference between good carbs & bad carbs, and good fats & bad fats. You need to know the best times to eat proteins, carbohydrates & fats relative to exercise (it's also really not that critical, but many people get it wrong). You need to know the difference between good exercise & bad exercise.
Continued on We are not all the same.