Showing posts with label Postprandial hunger. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Postprandial hunger. Show all posts

Friday, 4 July 2014

How low & very low-carbohydrate diets result in more weight loss than high-carbohydrate diets for people with Insulin Resistance or Type 2 Diabetes.

See The Battle of the Diets: Is Anyone Winning (At Losing?) for trials where insulin resistant people lose more weight on low-carbohydrate diets than on high-carbohydrate diets and insulin sensitive people lose more weight on high-carbohydrate diets than on low-carbohydrate diets.

If Gary Taubes's carbohydrate/insulin hypothesis of obesity is correct, everyone would lose more weight on low-carbohydrate diets than on high-carbohydrate diets. This isn't the case, therefore Gary Taubes's hypothesis is NOT correct.

Although insulin is involved, it has nothing to do with "Hormonal clogs" or "Insulin fairies".
The Aragon Insulin Fairy

The Energy Balance Equation


Change in Body Stores = Energy in - Energy out, where... 

Energy in = Energy entering mouth - Energy exiting anus, and... 

Energy out = BMR/RMR + TEF + TEA + SPA/NEAT

See The Energy Balance Equation to find out what the above terms mean.

People with Insulin Resistance (IR), Impaired Glucose Tolerance (IGT) & Type 2 Diabetes (T2DM) have excessive insulin secretion in response to meals (postprandial hyperinsulinaemia). See Hyperinsulinaemia and Insulin Resistance - An Engineer's Perspective.

People with Insulin Resistance (IR), Impaired Glucose Tolerance (IGT) & Type 2 Diabetes (T2DM) also have impaired/no 1st phase insulin response to a sudden rise in blood glucose level. This introduces a time-lag into the negative feed-back (NFB) loop that regulates blood glucose level. If the input rise-time is less than the time-lag in a NFB loop, the output of the NFB loop overshoots. This is standard NFB loop behaviour. See Control of overshoot for more information.

1. On a high-refined-carbohydrate or high-GL diet, blood glucose level rises rapidly, with a rise-time that's less than the time-lag in the blood glucose regulation NFB loop. Insulin secretion from the pancreas overshoots in a positive direction. The resulting postprandial hyperinsulinaemia results in down-regulation of insulin receptors in the brain, which reduces insulin action in the brain. When the insulin level eventually falls to normal a few hours later, the brain interprets a normal insulin level as hypoinsulinaemia. Hypoinsulinaemia results in ravenous hunger, as insulin is a short-term satiety/satiation hormone in the brain (leptin is a long-term satiety/satiation hormone in the brain). Ravenous hunger results in over-eating. Energy in increases. Postprandial hyperinsulinaemia also results in postprandial sleepiness. Energy out decreases. Body stores increase. There are also accusations of gluttony & sloth!

2. On a low-carbohydrate or low-GL diet, there are small fluctuations in blood glucose & insulin levels. There is no ravenous hunger. There is much less/no over-eating. Energy in decreases. There is no massive postprandial hyperinsulinaemia. There is much less/no postprandial sleepiness. Energy out increases. Body stores decrease.

In addition, there is a loss of water weight due to a loss of liver & muscle glycogen. This can be ~2kg in one day (it varies from person to person). Kidneys can increase their output of urine for hormonal reasons. This can increase water weight loss to ~5kg. See Why counting Calories and weighing yourself regularly can be a waste of time.

There are also other hormones involved. For a Facebook discussion with James Krieger that led to the updating of this post, see https://www.facebook.com/james.krieger1/posts/10153228943648587

In Metabolic Ward studies, food intake is tightly controlled, so postprandial hunger doesn't result in over-eating. Energy expenditure is also controlled, so postprandial sleepiness doesn't significantly affect energy expenditure. This is why varying Fat:Carb ratios (with Protein held constant) makes no significant difference to weight in a Metabolic Ward. See Energy intake required to maintain body weight is not affected by wide variation in diet composition.

Inter-personal variations in postprandial hyperinsulinaemia, postprandial sleepiness & energy out explain the inter-personal variations in weight gain seen under hypercaloric conditions. See Bray et al shows that a calorie *is* a calorie (where weight change is concerned).

Insulin Resistance can be fixed. See Insulin Resistance: Solutions to problems.

Type 2 Diabetes can also be fixed. See Reversing type 2 diabetes, the lecture explaining T2D progression, and how to treat it.

Aim to fix the problem. If it's impossible to fix the problem, a low-carbohydrate diet as an adjunct to medication is fine.

Friday, 19 December 2008

It's all about ME, baby! (1997 - present)

If you're wondering "Who is this Nigeepoo geezer and why is he wittering on about Cholesterol, Diabetes & Vitamin D?", read on...

This story starts in 1997. I'd just come through an acrimonious divorce and I was tired, bloated, 17st 7lb and depressed. Then a pamphlet dropped through my letterbox. It was from Agora Lifestyles, promoting a book by a Dr. Robert C. Atkins. I didn't buy his book, but I read the pamphlet from cover to cover, and it described postprandial sleepiness followed by ravenous hunger after eating meals high in carbohydrate. Since childhood, I used to feel very sleepy after eating starchy meals but I never knew why. So, despite my disbelief that Atkins's diet could work, I cut out bread, pasta, potatoes, rice, cereals etc - all of the things that we are constantly told are good for us because they are "low-fat".

Within days, I felt like a new man. The postprandial sleepiness & ravenous hunger were gone, my weight slowly decreased and the heartburn I used to get was also gone. I was a total convert. By nature I'm very curious (which is why I became an Engineer), so I wondered how Atkins's diet worked. In 1999, I got Internet access at work and was delighted to see that there were people out there (some of them doctors) other than Atkins who were saying much the same thing.

In 2001, I got a shock when the company for which I'd worked for 24 years lost a "must win" contract and I was put on the redundancy list. My health began to deteriorate. My body temperature fell and in November 2002 I was admitted to hospital with renal colic caused by a uric acid kidney stone. I got to see an endocrinologist, who did tests and found that my pituitary gland wasn't secreting TSH, causing secondary hypothyroidism. I was prescribed levothyroxine. The upside is that I am now exempt from prescription charges. I also get annual blood tests, so that I can see the results of any diet/supplement/exercise change on my blood-work.

As well as having a dysfunctional pituitary, I also had "Metabolic Syndrome" (a.k.a. "Syndrome-X" in the US). This is a fancy name for pre-type 2 diabetes and it's caused by Insulin Resistance (IR). This meant that my fasting serum glucose, triglycerides, total cholesterol, LDL & uric acid were high and my HDL was low. A diet lower in sugary & starchy carbohydrates suits people with this condition.

I didn't know how Atkins's diet worked, so I studied some biochemistry web-sites to get a better understanding of human metabolism. In November 2002, I joined the Muscletalk forum after e-mailing James Collier B.Sc. (Hons) - Moderator and Contributor to Muscletalk as an Expert in Nutrition, criticising his negative article on ketogenic diets. Username "Nigeepoo" was born. Why Nigeepoo? I have a rather odd sense of humour and think that putting "poo" on the end of a word is hilarious. It also suits my warm & fluffy nature!

This was the beginning of a new phase in my learning. From there, I found a US & then a Canadian (now closed) body-building forum which allowed me to learn even more about nutrition. In January 2003, the BBC series "Diet Trials" studied the Atkins diet amongst others. At the end of the series, viewers were referred to a BBC Nutrition & Fitness board (now closed) and a Healthy eating board (now a Food Q&A board) where I posted. As a result of various recommendations, I bought some books on running, diet & nutrition, metabolism and biochemistry. I also surfed PubMed and various journals, looking for studies on ketogenic diets and the effects of different proteins, fats and carbohydrates on subjects. See How stuff works.

In 2004, my pituitary stopped secreting sufficient LH & FSH and in 2005 it stopped secreting sufficient GH, so I decided to take early retirement and take things a bit easier as I was having trouble with my memory & concentration. I decided to dump my nutritional knowledge to hard-copy before I forgot it, so I wrote an e-book, "Nigee's Guide to Losing Body-fat Healthily". That's not the only reason why I wrote it....you'll have to read it to find out the other one. Was that hint subtle enough? Please note that the information in the e-book is frozen and is now completely out-of-date. The information in this blog is kept up-to-date.

Discovering Vitamin D3 at the beginning of 2007 was a major breakthrough, in terms of memory, concentration, mood and the Metabolic Syndrome. My endocrinologist was so pleased with my last set of blood and urine tests (all normal except for slightly raised cholesterol) that I don't need to see him any more. I still have annual blood tests, to monitor my condition.

Discovering the bad effects of a sedentary lifestyle at the end of 2010 was another major breakthrough in terms of tackling IR. See Insulin Resistance: Solutions to problems.

Right, that's enough about me, baby! Tomorrow, it's back to boring old nutritional stuff again.

Cheers, Nige.

Wednesday, 17 December 2008

Blood Glucose, Insulin & Diabetes

Diabetes is afflicting an increasing percentage of the population as time goes by. Even athletes like Sir Steven Redgrave can get it. This article tries to explain the workings of the body's blood glucose (BG) regulation system and what can go wrong with it.


How does the body regulate blood glucose?

At any given moment, there's ~4.5g of glucose in your blood (5mmol/L x 180g x 5L). As the brain alone uses about 6g of glucose per hour in the absence of ketones, blood glucose (BG) level could fall to zero within an hour if we ate no sugary/starchy carbs. If we ate a mere 5g of glucose, BG level could double. As very low BGs are fatal and very high BGs damage proteins by a process called glycation (a bit like caramelisation), the body keeps BG levels within fairly tight limits by the use of a negative feedback (NFB) control system.


How does a negative feedback control system work?

NFB systems consist of a non-inverting (more in → more out) part, which in this case are the islet cells of Langerhans (a.k.a. pancreatic beta cells), as increasing BG level results in increasing insulin secretion. It's actually more complicated than that. Beta cells can store insulin and dump it into the blood if there is a sudden increase in BG level. This is analogous to the accelerator pump in a carburettor, which dumps petrol into the engine if you slam your foot on the accelerator pedal, i.e. it produces a rapid response. The dumping of insulin from beta cell storage is known as the 1st Phase insulin response. If this (or the accelerator pump) fails, there is a lag in the response; this will become significant below.

Increasing BG level results in increasing insulin secretion from beta cells and is known as the 2nd Phase insulin response.

The other part of a NFB system is the inverting (more in → less out) feedback part, which in this case is split into three parts, all working in parallel. They are:
  1. Liver - increasing insulin level results in decreasing Hepatic Glucose Production.
  2. Muscle cells - increasing insulin level shifts GLU-T4 transporters which shuttle glucose from the blood into cells, decreasing BG level.
  3. Fat cells - increasing insulin level shifts GLU-T4 transporters which shuttle glucose from the blood into cells, decreasing BG level.


What can go wrong?

There are three main types of diabetes:

1) Type 2 diabetes. This is by far the most common (about 95% of all cases) and is usually caused by abdominal obesity. Type 2 diabetes has two main mechanisms going on. The first is a progressive insulin resistance (IR) of target tissues, possibly caused by increased levels of saturated fatty acids being fed to the liver from abdominal fat stores, chronically-high BG and insulin levels caused by chronically over-consuming high glycaemic load carbohydrates, possibly accompanied by large amounts of saturated fat and/or large amounts of omega-6 fat. A sedentary lifestyle lowers the sensitivity of muscle cells to insulin. Insulin resistance also has a hereditary link. IR is reversible. See Insulin Resistance: Solutions to problems.

Insulin resistance weakens the feedback in the NFB system, resulting in increased BG level (hyperglycaemia) and increased insulin level (hyperinsulinaemia). See Hyperinsulinaemia and Insulin Resistance - An Engineer's Perspective. Increased BG level causes increased damage to beta cells by glycation. Increased insulin level gradually causes further insulin resistance as target tissues become increasingly insensitive (a bit like louder and louder music making you progressively deafer and deafer). Eventually, beta cells become too damaged to secrete sufficient insulin and insulin levels begin to fall. This results in a massive rise in BG level and this is now full-blown Type 2 diabetes. There are five main treatments for Type 2 diabetes:
  1. Lifestyle interventions - reduced intake of high glycaemic load carbohydrates and/or increased intake of omega-3 fats and/or increased intake of Vitamin D3 and/or increased intense exercise and/or loss of abdominal fat.
  2. Sulphonylureas - drugs which stimulate beta cells to secrete even more insulin. Unfortunately, that's a bit like flogging a dying horse as it doesn't address the problems caused by weakened feedback and eventual beta cell failure is inevitable, resulting in the need for insulin injections.
  3. Biguanide drugs such as Metformin - increase insulin sensitivity in target tissues. This strengthens the feedback in the NFB system, which results in reduced BG and insulin levels. This combined with lifestyle interventions can return the NFB system to normal operation.
  4. Thiazolidinediones - also increase insulin sensitivity in target tissues, e.g. muscle and fat, as well as possibly improving the secretory function of beta cells. Increases the number of new, empty fat cells.
  5. Insulin injections take the strain off beta cells, but may worsen insulin resistance.

2) Type 1 diabetes. This is much less common (about 5% of all diabetes cases) and is caused by an autoimmune disease. One possible mechanism is as follows: Due to an increase in Zonulin, the gut becomes more permeable than it should (a.k.a. Leaky Gut), which allows protein fragments to pass into the blood. These are locked-onto by antibodies, and destroyed by the immune system. However, if a protein fragment happens to have the same sequence of amino acids as a protein in your body, the immune system sets about destroying parts of your own body. Examples of this are gluten (proteins found in wheat, rye, barley and oats) producing antibodies in the blood that can destroy the gut causing Coeliac Disease, or skin cells causing Dermatitis Herpetiformis, or mucous membranes causing Sjogren's Syndrome, or brain cells causing Cerebellar Ataxia. As there's an association between the consumption of cows' milk and the incidence of type 1 diabetes (see here ), it's possible that, in susceptible individuals, casein protein fragments enter the blood, resulting in auto-immune destruction of pancreatic beta cells. Another possible mechanism is autoimmune attack after a viral infection. Once all beta cells have been destroyed, no insulin is secreted and insulin injections are required. If some beta cells survive, there's a possibility that normal BG levels can be maintained if sugary/starchy carbohydrate intake is reduced.

3) Latent Autoimmune Diabetes of Adulthood (LADA). This is a slow developing diabetes that is more like type 1 in origin (autoimmune with antibodies) but is often misdiagnosed as type 2 because of the age at diagnosis and the relatively slow progression of the disease (slow compared to type 1 but fast compared to type 2). It is believed that Sir Steven Redgrave has this. Whether or not his autoimmune disease was triggered by a huge intake of milk (to build those Olympic-winning muscles), we'll never know. To minimise your risk of developing autoimmune diseases, see Keep 'em tight.



What else can go wrong?

As stated earlier, loss of the 1st Phase insulin response can occur. This usually happens when beta cells are chronically over-secreting insulin due to a chronically-high intake of sugary/starchy carbs and are unable to store any. This results in a lag in insulin response. This isn't a problem if low glycaemic load carbs are eaten and BG levels change only a little or very slowly. However, if high glycaemic load carbs are eaten, this produces a rapid rise in BG level. If a NFB loop with a lag in it is presented with a step response change in input level, its output overshoots. This results in too much insulin being secreted (a.k.a. postprandial hyperinsulinaemia), which causes feelings of postprandial sleepiness and also down-regulates insulin receptors in the ventromedial hypothalamus (VMH), resulting in an eventual normal insulin level being interpreted by the VMH as rebound hypoinsulinaemia, which causes feelings of ravenous hunger (as insulin acts as a satiety/satiation hormone in the brain). The solution? Stick to low glycaemic load carbs.


Where does blood glucose come from if I haven't eaten?

When no sugary/starchy carbs are being digested, BG starts to fall. Adrenaline and noradrenaline (catecholamine hormones) are secreted by the adrenal medulla into the blood and also by sympathetic neurons. Like glucagon (see below), they stimulate the mobilisation of glycogen and triacylglycerols (stored fats) by triggering the production of cyclic AMP (adenosine mono-phosphate). Adrenaline and noradrenaline differ from glucagon in that their glucose-producing effect is greater in muscle glycogen than in liver. They also inhibit the uptake of glucose by muscle. Instead, fatty acids released from adipose tissue are used as fuel. Adrenaline also stimulates the secretion of glucagon and inhibits the secretion of insulin. Thus, catecholamines such as adrenaline and noradrenaline increase the amount of glucose released into the blood by the liver and decrease the utilization of glucose by muscle.

Pancreatic alpha cells secrete glucagon. This hormone mobilises the conversion of liver glycogen into glucose. The liver only stores about 70g of glycogen, but when combined with water, a larger mass of glucose is generated. Eventually, liver glycogen stores become depleted and BG level falls again. Glucagon also stimulates gluconeogenesis in the liver & kidneys, which is the production of glucose from non-carbohydrate precursors, like the conversion of glucogenic amino acids, such as glutamine, into glucose. This causes slow muscle wastage unless there is sufficient protein intake to provide the necessary amino acids. When BG falls to about 3.3mmol/L, the pituitary kicks-in and secretes ACTH (adrenocorticotropic hormone) which stimulates the release of cortisol from the adrenal cortex. Cortisol further stimulates gluconeogenesis in the liver & kidneys by catabolising (breaking down) muscle mass. When BG level falls to about 2mmol/L, the pituitary secretes GH (Growth Hormone) which has an anti-insulin effect.


What else does insulin do?

Insulin has many metabolic effects in the body apart from lowering BG level. It's a very anabolic hormone and an insulin spike is usually desired post workout to maximise the uptake of glucose and amino acids by muscle cells. There's nothing wrong with the occasional short-term insulin spike. It's chronically-high insulin levels due to chronic overconsumption &/or insulin resistance that cause long-term health problems like high blood pressure and clogging of arteries.